Kerry's Campaign Asked a Veteran
to Change Story
KANSAS MEETING AT ISSUE: by THOMAS H. LIPSCOMB Special to the (NYC)
Sun
A Vietnam veteran who said he remembers John Kerry
participating in a 1971 Kansas City meeting at which an assassination plot
was discussed says an official with the Kerry presidential campaign called
him this month and pressured him to change his story.
The veteran, John Musgrave, says he was called twice
by the head of Veterans for Kerry, John Hurley, while a reporter for the
Kansas City Star worked on a follow-up piece to a New York Sun article
about the November 1971 meeting of Vietnam Veterans Against the War at
which a plot to kill U.S. senators was voted down. Asked by The New York
Sun if he felt pressured, Mr. Musgrave said, “In the second call I did.”
Mr. Musgrave said Mr. Hurley said Mr. Kerry had told him “he was definitely
not in Kansas City.”
According to Mr. Musgrave, Mr. Hurley said, “Why
don’t you refresh your memory and call that reporter back?”
A spokesman for Mr. Kerry’s presidential campaign,
David Wade, last week issued a statement to the Sun, following a week of
denials, that said “we accept” Mr. Kerry’s presence in Kansas City as a
“historical footnote.”
By then, the recollections of six witnesses, along
with minutes and FBI records, placed Mr. Kerry at the Kansas City meeting.
But the news of the calls from the campaign to Mr.
Musgrave may move the episode from what the campaign is describing as a
“historical footnote” to a matter that involves the contemporary behavior
of Mr. Kerry and his campaign.
Mr. Musgrave said he received three Purple Hearts
in Vietnam. After the third Purple Heart for wounds by three 7.62 rounds,
one to the jaw and two to the left chest, Mr. Musgrave refused the standard
release from further service in the combat zone offered Marines with three
Purple Hearts and
tried to return to his unit, he said.
But because of the extent of his injuries he was
retired from the Marines with full disability and sent home, he said.
Mr. Musgrave said, “I told Hurley it was my first
meeting as a state officer of the VVAW, and I remember John being there.
I remember what I remember.”
When asked whom he is supporting in the presidential
election, Mr. Musgrave replied, “I am undecided. But I am sure not voting
for some guy who called me a liar.”
Mr. Hurley did not return calls for comment for this
article.
Another related episode in which the Kerry campaign
had to handle questions about Vietnam Veterans Against the War involves
a statement by Mr. Kerry himself.
At a Capitol Hill press conference on March 11,
2004, Mr. Kerry was asked by a reporter if he thought his credibility had
been affected by his close association with Al Hubbard, a key VVAW colleague
of Mr. Kerry’s who had appointed him to the leadership of the Vietnam Veterans
Against the
War.
Mr. Hubbard claimed to be a wounded Air Force officer
who had served at Danang during the Vietnam War. He appeared with Mr. Kerry
many times, including the “Meet the Press” interview after Mr.Kerry’s Senate
testimony about American “war crimes” in Vietnam.
But Mr. Hubbard was never in Vietnam, was never wounded,
and was not an officer, as subsequent research and Mr. Kerry himself have
pointed out.
Mr. Kerry answered this month that he had not spoken
to Mr.Hubbard since the week of April 19, 1971.
Yet the Kerry campaign now apparently accepts that
Mr. Kerry was at the November 12 to 15, 1971,VVAW meeting. Mr. Musgrave
said he remembers that at that meeting, Mr. Kerry challenged Mr. Hubbard’s
continuing to maintain his false claims to being an Air Force officer wounded
at Danang.
“Hubbard sort of sat there with his eyes downcast
and Mike Oliver really did all the arguing for him,” Mr. Musgrave said.
“And suddenly Hubbard got up and said he was having an ulcer attack and
had to get to New York immediately to see his doctor and ran out of the
room.You would think we didn’t have any doctors or hospitals in Kansas
City.”
In addition, the New York Times reported on an August
29, 1971, fundraising party for the Vietnam Veterans Against the War at
which “Mr. Kerry and Al Hubbard, another veteran, explained some of the
aims of the organization.”
| Column text © 2004 Thomas Lipscomb, who is the founder
of (New York) Times Books, and was the publisher of ADM Elmo Zumwalt’s
bestselling ON WATCH. Presently, he heads the Center for the Digital
Future and is a nationally-known columnist, appearing in major U.S. newspapers. |
|